La Herradura - Peekskill

4.4 305 reviews Closed 118 N Division St, Peekskill, NY 10566, United States

Discover this place

La Herradura is a Guatemalan restaurant located in Peekskill, NY, offering a diverse menu rooted in traditional Central American cuisine. The restaurant features classic dishes such as pupusas, stewed red snapper, churrasco chapin, and various grilled steak options like bistek chapin and sirloin in shrimp sauce. The menu also includes popular accompaniments like fried sweet plantains, fried green plantains with rice and salad, and sweet tamal desserts, including sweet corn tamal with cheese and cream.

The atmosphere at La Herradura reflects its cultural heritage, aiming to provide an authentic dining experience through its carefully prepared dishes. With a focus on both traditional combos—like tacos and pupusas—and seafood options such as tilapia fillets and breaded shrimp, the restaurant balances land and sea flavors characteristic of Guatemalan cuisine. Beverage choices include classic cocktails such as piña coladas and mojitos, complementing the meals.

La Herradura stands out as a notable local spot by showcasing the depth and variety of Guatemalan culinary traditions within a straightforward, approachable setting. Its menu offers a comprehensive look at regional flavors and preparations, making it a distinctive destination for those seeking Central American fare in the Peekskill area.

Photos

Amenities & More

Service options

Takeout
Dine-in

Highlights

Fast service
Great beer selection
Great cocktails
Serves local specialty
Sports

Popular for

Breakfast
Lunch
Dinner
Solo dining

Dining options

Breakfast
Brunch
Lunch
Dinner
Dessert
Seating
Table service

Amenities

Bar onsite
Restroom

Atmosphere

Casual
Cozy
Quiet
Trendy

Crowd

Groups
Tourists

Note: Amenity details are aggregated from verified visits, the venue's website and Google. They may change without notice. We recommend confirming key details (pet policy, accessibility, reservations) directly with La Herradura - Peekskill before visiting.

Reviews for La Herradura - Peekskill

4.4

305 reviews

100%

28%

10%

Review highlights

Based on 305 reviews

La Herradura is widely recognized for its authentic Guatemalan cuisine, consistently praised for delivering traditional flavors and generous portions. Reviewers frequently highlight standout dishes such as the sweet corn tamal and pupusas, noting their exceptional taste. The restaurant’s atmosphere is described as homey and relaxed, offering an experience that reflects genuine cultural roots rather than typical American dining vibes. Customer service is commonly noted as friendly and attentive, with many appreciating the personalized attention from staff familiar with regular patrons. Additionally, the clean and quiet setting complements the overall dining experience, making it a favored stop for both locals and travelers. While prices are considered reasonable for the quality and quantity offered, the emphasis remains on authenticity and a welcoming environment rather than upscale ambiance.

Laura Nugra

Jul 22, 2025

The pupusas were delicious!BUT THE SWEET CORN TAMAL OMG IT WAS SOOO GOOOD!!!IF YOU GO HERE I DEFENETLY RECOMMEND YOU TO GET THE SWEET CORN TAMAL!!!!

Hefzi-bá Beula

Jul 03, 2025

Me encanta. We simply love it because they love us back!

CDA

May 24, 2025

The food is amazing. Great taste nice presentation and huge portions. The staff is friendly and attentive. Prices are great too. My girlfriend and I have been there twice and plan to stop in whenever were in the area. Its a great pit stop between Manhattan and a day at bear mountain. Nice clean little town. The restaurant and surrounding area is clean and quiet. We love the food!!

kathy p

May 24, 2025

This is as traditional as traditional can get for Guatemalan food. This restaurant offers authentic food and even the way it’s laid out is just like in my country. Please do not come here expecting service or vibes like American restaurants. This is a homey authentic and relaxed environment. If you’re looking for clean delicious flavor this is it.

Eddie O

May 02, 2025

Amazing food and a the price is okay. La parilla is literally for two people but I can finish 85% myself The staff is also amazing the know me by name.

Dan

Apr 13, 2025

Ceviche was outstanding and so was the chicken soup! I forgot to take pics but I did take pics of the menu because they don't have any takeout menus or website lol so im tryna help this small biz out.

Marc Starvaggi

Apr 13, 2025

Very good food at very good prices. Loved my lomo saltado. It's the most you can ask for a place. Out of all the similar restaurants in the area, La Herradura stands out.